Guilty as Sock!

Guilty as Sock!

Steam Deck Playable

Demon Max · Multiplayer · May 29, 2025

Yes, worth buying.

At $5.50. It has been as low as $4.40.

90%
Very Positive
6k player reviews
High confidence
Buy it if you like
  • Multiplayer: 48 reviews raised it, mostly praise
  • Story and characters: 11 reviews raised it, mostly praise
  • Gameplay: 10 reviews raised it, mostly praise
Think twice if you dislike
  • No recurring complaint surfaced in 300 sampled reviews

Based on 6k player reviews · updated 3 days ago

What players think

The recurring themes across 300 analysed reviews: what players praise, what divides them, and what to know.

Why players love itThings to know
100% of themes are praise300 helpful reviews0% are caveats
Multiplayer
Players who bring up Multiplayer mostly praise it.
I get that this was done for the sake of lower player counts, but I would like to see larger lobbies in the future that can allow for at least 2 on each side or something similar so people can work together on a case and have to agree on their arguments.
48 of 300 sampled reviews raised it
Story and characters
Players who bring up Story and characters mostly praise it.
There are also a few characters where their entire purpose is to draw funny visual gags, like the reporter and the jurors, so people with art tablets will have more fun with that than 90% of players that will have a mouse, but I'm sure this game will have a brief resurgence if a group of D&D streamers take a shine to it and stream themselves making funny content with the doodling mechanics.
11 of 300 sampled reviews raised it
Gameplay
Players who bring up Gameplay mostly praise it.
The replayability is genuinely impressive; from changing roles, new charges, fresh evidence, and the recently added roles ... all keep the game feeling new every time you launch it.
10 of 300 sampled reviews raised it

Theme by theme

Every theme is scored by what reviewers actually said about it, not just whether they recommended the game.

LovedMixedComplained about
Players love3 themes
Multiplayer48 reviews
Story and characters11 reviews
Gameplay10 reviews
Divided opinion% still recommend

No themes split opinion in this sample.

Players complain% still recommend

No recurring complaints surfaced in this sample.

Ranked by how many sampled reviews mention each topic. A topic sits in a column by what reviewers said about that topic; the percentage beside it is how many of them recommended the game anyway. 2 more themes were each raised by fewer than 6 sampled reviews and are not shown.

Should you buy it now?

Crit’s read on the price, from Steam price history.

Prices have been lower

Currently $5.50. The lowest we've tracked is $4.40.

3 points recordedtoday · $5.50

The data behind the verdict

For the players who want the receipts.

Player review score
90%
Very Positive
Playing right now
Achievements
31
total to unlock
Rarest-achievement stats coming soon
Average playtime
Not tracked yet

We’ll surface hours-played once playtime ingestion ships.

If you liked this one

Reviewed games that overlap most with this one.

No recommendations for this game yet.

This game doesn’t overlap enough with games Crit has reviewed.